Love Me Tender was released 70 years ago, on November 15, 1956. The film followed Elvis Presley’s iconic song, also titled “Love Me Tender,” by just over one month. And as it turns out, the popularity of the now-legendary single had a major impact on the big-screen blockbuster that would later share the name.
Seven decades ago, a young 21-year-old Presley was tapped to star in his first movie. While “The King’s” music career was already on fire, the film wasn’t originally a musical. That’s right, Presley’s first movie didn’t include a song — and it wasn’t even called Love Me Tender. Instead, the flick was titled The Reno Brothers.
The Civil War-era western featured a melodramatic love triangle between Presley (as Clint Reno), his older brother Vance (Richard Egan), and Cathy (Debra Paget). While fans may think of Presley as a headliner, he didn’t receive top billing. Instead, Egan (who also starred in A Summer Place, Pollyanna, and The 300 Spartans) was the star of this show. According to TCM, Egan mentored the young Presley, helping him through his first role.
Surprisingly, Presley wasn’t the first pick for the character. TCM notes that Robert Wagner and a host of other young actors were also up for the part. Of course, Presley won the supporting role and made cinematic history.
How did a film that wasn’t supposed to be a musical end up with four well-known songs? After Presley signed on, the producers took advantage of the opportunity and reworked the script to include original music.
Now known as a chart-topper that stayed at No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 for five weeks, “Love Me Tender” (the song) was the brainchild of songwriter Ken Darby. With the movie’s theme in mind, Darby adapted the 1861 Civil War ballad “Aura Lee” into the Elvis hit. Music executives at RCA-Victor were so impressed by Presley’s recording that they released the song before the film, according to the American Film Institute.
After the budding movie star sang the single on the Ed Sullivan Show, 20th Century Fox decided to change the movie’s title from The Reno Brothers to Love Me Tender.
Even though Presley is an icon now, back in 1956, The New Yorker film critic John McCarten had this objectively unflattering review of Elvis in his first film: “Whose talents are meager but whose earnings are gross, excites a large section of the young female population as nobody else has ever done, and I approached this movie with a certain amount of middle-aged trepidation. Unhappily, my fears were well founded.”
Like The New Yorker, Time’s critique of Presley’s performance wasn’t entirely glowing. But after comparing Presley to a 172-pound sausage, the review does go on to read, “In his first screen appearance, with four songs and a secondary role as the hero’s little brother in an otherwise routine south western, Elvis Presley all but steals the show from such better-known players as Richard Egan, Debra Paget, and Mildred Dunnock.”
Regardless of the reviews, fans couldn’t get enough of the rock ‘n’ roll star on the big screen. Presley would go on to star in more than 30 feature films, including Jailhouse Rock, Blue Hawaii, Girls! Girls! Girls!, and Viva Las Vegas.