Ashley Williams, Lacey Chabert, Jonathan Bennett, and Tamera Mowry-Housley have hosted reality shows for Hallmark.Hallmark
The Hallmark Channel is shifting gears with its programming, and it is a move that fans will likely be thrilled to see. After previously hyping its movement toward “Reality TV with Heart,” Hallmark is now pulling back on its unscripted programming.
Hallmark president Darren Abbott recently talked with The Wrap about the network’s decision.
“I’m a big believer in iteration and innovation,” Abbott shared. He continued, “and part of innovating successfully is being able to learn from what you’re doing, really zeroing in on the insights, and also acknowledging when things resonate and when they may not.”
Abbott added, “Relative to other parts of the service and other genres, you’ll probably see us lean more into scripted series, movies, exclusive content and probably less focus on unscripted moving forward.”
However, Abbott noted, Hallmark knows that some of its unscripted shows are “beloved by segments of our audience.” That suggests that some unscripted shows will likely return, but viewers won’t see as many launched as they did in the past year or two.
Lacey Chabert hosted Halllmark's 'Celebrations' series.Hallmark Media
Hallmark+ has already debuted several scripted series exclusive to the streaming platform. Hope Valley: 1874, a prequel to When Calls the Heart, had a successful first season on Hallmark+ and is renewed for a second season. In addition, Lacey Chabert is headlining the limited-run series Paris Is Always a Good Idea, which fans have responded to quite positively.
Previous unscripted shows that have aired on Hallmark+ include Jonathan Bennett‘s Finding Mr. Christmas, which has aired two seasons, as well as Chabert’s Celebrations, which has also aired two seasons. Tamera Mowry-Housley hosted Baked With Love: Holiday, and Connie Britton headlined The Motherhood.
Matthew Lawrence and Chilli hosted Hallmark's 'Second Chance at Love'Hallmark Media
Home Is Where the Heart Is starred Luke Macfarlane, and Ashley Williams headlined Small Town Setup. The network gave a dating show a try with Second Chance, hosted by Matthew Lawrence and Chilli, and in May, Erin Cahill debuted as the host of Mom’s the Bride.
The programming shift away from unscripted shows was previously referenced in a statement to Realscreen in February, as well. “Our unscripted content remains a valuable tool to provide our viewers with real-life stories that capture the Hallmark purpose, lifestyle and fandom,” the statement read.
It continued, “We are constantly examining our content and refining to meet the needs and desires of our audience. To that end, we are transitioning our work in the unscripted area to include a limited number of specials and limited series at impactful times throughout the year, versus a full concurrent slate.”
Tamera Mowry-Housley hosted Hallmark's 'Baked With Love: Holiday.'Hallmark Media
Hallmark’s previous push toward more unscripted offerings did not necessarily resonate well with fans. The shift back to more traditional Hallmark programming will likely be celebrated by viewers.
On Reddit, one person noted, “Horrible idea to go ‘unscripted.’ You watch Hallmark to NOT watch ‘unscripted.'”
Another shared, “I’m really not liking this trend. I wish they would invest this capital and talent into more movies year-round.”
So far, Hallmark does not appear to have made any formal announcements about new seasons of existing unscripted shows, like Finding Mr. Christmas or Celebrations.